17th November 2026, 12:31 PM
Well, my steady progression politically has shifted so much I'm of almost the exact opposite position I used to be in regarding total automation. Almost.
The key problem with a lot of this tech is... the rest of how we have society structured at present. So long as the automation is owned by an elite class of CEOs, it won't benefit the majority of us. I've been reading up more on the Luddites, and frankly contrary to the cartoonish portrayal they formerly had, I kind of admire them, in the way I kind of admire the Amish (the "Amish Amish", I mean, not those "we use the internet and drive in cars but we like to keep calling ourselves Amish" Amish). Their objection to the oncoming factory tech was how it completely drove them out of business and into complete servitude towards those who owned the new factories, who themselves weren't making anything but simply ran things by virtue of being land owners. It was a shift from towns being more or less able to run on their own to towns utterly dependent on one Big Man. So, it's a lot more understandable why they'd go around destroying the factory machines they saw as a threat to a whole way of life and self sufficiency. Ultimately, laws were changed with death penalties put in place for anyone who broke a factory machine, and that brought an end to the Luddite movement.
Likewise, it comes down to that "workers should own the means of production" mindset, and that the public needs to have some say in the way of life their own city engages in. A fully automated store becomes something of a turnkey operation, and one land owner with no need of employees ends up hogging up the space, both physically and economically, that a whole lot of people previously depended on to make a living. Spread that out, with any such automated store being owned in equal measure by every individual working for it, and put restrictions on just what "contract labor" actually entails, and it makes it a lot more palatable.
The key problem with a lot of this tech is... the rest of how we have society structured at present. So long as the automation is owned by an elite class of CEOs, it won't benefit the majority of us. I've been reading up more on the Luddites, and frankly contrary to the cartoonish portrayal they formerly had, I kind of admire them, in the way I kind of admire the Amish (the "Amish Amish", I mean, not those "we use the internet and drive in cars but we like to keep calling ourselves Amish" Amish). Their objection to the oncoming factory tech was how it completely drove them out of business and into complete servitude towards those who owned the new factories, who themselves weren't making anything but simply ran things by virtue of being land owners. It was a shift from towns being more or less able to run on their own to towns utterly dependent on one Big Man. So, it's a lot more understandable why they'd go around destroying the factory machines they saw as a threat to a whole way of life and self sufficiency. Ultimately, laws were changed with death penalties put in place for anyone who broke a factory machine, and that brought an end to the Luddite movement.
Likewise, it comes down to that "workers should own the means of production" mindset, and that the public needs to have some say in the way of life their own city engages in. A fully automated store becomes something of a turnkey operation, and one land owner with no need of employees ends up hogging up the space, both physically and economically, that a whole lot of people previously depended on to make a living. Spread that out, with any such automated store being owned in equal measure by every individual working for it, and put restrictions on just what "contract labor" actually entails, and it makes it a lot more palatable.
"On two occasions, I have been asked [by members of Parliament], 'Pray, Mr. Babbage, if you put into the machine wrong figures, will the right answers come out?' I am not able to rightly apprehend the kind of confusion of ideas that could provoke such a question." ~ Charles Babbage (1791-1871)