9th November 2026, 9:50 AM
(This post was last modified: 9th November 2026, 9:54 AM by Dark Jaguar.)
I found a wonderful translation of an old interview with the developers, and here's Miyamoto's thoughts on the Navi(gation) hint system.
Miyamoto: "I think the way we give hints is still a little too unfriendly. Speaking plainly, I can now confess to you: I think the whole system with Navi giving you advice is the biggest weakpoint of Ocarina of Time. It's incredibly difficult to design a system that gives proper advice, advice that's tailored to the player's situation. To do it right, you'd have to spend the same amount of time as you would developing an entire game, and I was very worried we'd be digging ourselves into a hole, if we pursued perfection there…
If you read Navi's text, she says the same things over and over. I know it makes it sound bad, but we purposely left her at a kind of "stupid" level. I think if we'd tried to make Navi's hints more sophisticated, that "stupidity" would have actually stood out even more. The truth is I wanted to remove the entire system, but that would have been even more unfriendly to players. You can think of Navi as being there for players who stop playing for a month or so, who then pick the game back up and want to remember what they were supposed to do. It's a brazen excuse, I know. (laughs)
Otherwise, we tried to make the hints friendly for players, but I heard many people saying how they couldn't solve them without a strategy guide. When we took a closer look, though, we've found that the sections people need hints for vary from person-to-person. There's no consistency. That can't be helped, though, in a game like Zelda which combines action and puzzle solving."
It seems in the new one a few of the puzzles were altered a bit. In some cases, it's to gel better with the internal logic of the world. In other cases, it appears they wanted to primarily remove a few points where puzzle solving required some action worked in with it. Navi also makes random asides, but generally these are more comments than hints. For my part, I think the ideal solution involves a "puzzle difficulty" option, but being realistic, GameFAQs is still there as it ever was, and people are making guide videos now too. Any game with particularly hard puzzles is only a brief search away from a solution. I think it's better to err on the side of challenge than to make the puzzles feel so trivial you wonder why they were even there.
Miyamoto: "I think the way we give hints is still a little too unfriendly. Speaking plainly, I can now confess to you: I think the whole system with Navi giving you advice is the biggest weakpoint of Ocarina of Time. It's incredibly difficult to design a system that gives proper advice, advice that's tailored to the player's situation. To do it right, you'd have to spend the same amount of time as you would developing an entire game, and I was very worried we'd be digging ourselves into a hole, if we pursued perfection there…
If you read Navi's text, she says the same things over and over. I know it makes it sound bad, but we purposely left her at a kind of "stupid" level. I think if we'd tried to make Navi's hints more sophisticated, that "stupidity" would have actually stood out even more. The truth is I wanted to remove the entire system, but that would have been even more unfriendly to players. You can think of Navi as being there for players who stop playing for a month or so, who then pick the game back up and want to remember what they were supposed to do. It's a brazen excuse, I know. (laughs)
Otherwise, we tried to make the hints friendly for players, but I heard many people saying how they couldn't solve them without a strategy guide. When we took a closer look, though, we've found that the sections people need hints for vary from person-to-person. There's no consistency. That can't be helped, though, in a game like Zelda which combines action and puzzle solving."
It seems in the new one a few of the puzzles were altered a bit. In some cases, it's to gel better with the internal logic of the world. In other cases, it appears they wanted to primarily remove a few points where puzzle solving required some action worked in with it. Navi also makes random asides, but generally these are more comments than hints. For my part, I think the ideal solution involves a "puzzle difficulty" option, but being realistic, GameFAQs is still there as it ever was, and people are making guide videos now too. Any game with particularly hard puzzles is only a brief search away from a solution. I think it's better to err on the side of challenge than to make the puzzles feel so trivial you wonder why they were even there.
"On two occasions, I have been asked [by members of Parliament], 'Pray, Mr. Babbage, if you put into the machine wrong figures, will the right answers come out?' I am not able to rightly apprehend the kind of confusion of ideas that could provoke such a question." ~ Charles Babbage (1791-1871)